Teenagers scream for idols
A talent show was the TV event of the summer. It might also go down as the
Cincinnati teen-music concert of the year.
The 10 finalists from Fox's hit show American Idol have stepped out from the
small screen and hit the road for a nationwide tour, which stopped at U.S. Bank
Arena Friday.
"American Idols - The Top Ten" showcases the twin phenomena of reality
television and boy (or girl)-band pop. With a backup band in place all night,
each of the performers had a solo turn in the first set, beginning with
10th-place finisher EJay Day and ending with American Idol Kelly Clarkson. The
second set featured ensemble pieces plus additional solo performances from the
Final Four: Justin Guarini, Nikki McKibbin, Tamyra Gray and Ms.
Clarkson.
Seeing their two-dimensional heroes and heartthrobs come to life on stage
presented the audience members the impossible task of containing their joy. The
screams were at times 'NSync-loud, despite the fact that most of the upper-tier
seating was empty.
Three of the 10 received the loudest screams - Ms. Clarkson, Mr. Guarini and
Ms. Gray.
The first set was ballad-heavy, but Ms. Gray went with "I'm Every
Woman," a strange choice considering it was more of a beat-driven disco
song than a opportunity for the 23-year-old to show her vocal abilities. She
went with the ballad "A House is Not a Home" in the second set and
showed why she's a crowd favorite.
Mr. Guarini, he of the mop-like, tightly curled coiffure, was the most
polished stage performer of the group, naturally interacting with the band and
calmly and confidently working the crowd. The 23-year-old's version of Al
Green's "Let's Stay Together" was solid, either because he's a good
singer or because it's a good song.
The giddy Ms. Clarkson, 20, seemed to be riding high not only on her American
Idol win but the success of her hit "A Moment Like This."
Unfortunately her seemingly uncontrollable habit of pointing out random sights
in the stands - cardboard signs bearing her name, cotton-candy vendors - will be
remembered as much as her performances of "Respect" and "Before
Your Love."